Nick J. October 4, 2020
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive fans have become more aware of the Esports Integrity Commission recently when they found 34 coaches guilty of exploiting a spectating bug. But who exactly is the ESIC?
The Esports Integrity Commission was formed in 2016, representing a portion of the tournament organizers in Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. The commission was established in 2016 as esports had just started to grow, but their involvement in the recent CSGO coaching scandal has raised some questions. Does the ESIC actually work for any one organizer? Is it a neutral overseer or does it owe something to its members?
Who do the ESIC coaching rulings apply to?
The ESIC’s ruling on any esports matter only appy to organizations that are members of the ESIC. These tournament organizers are contractually required to follow the ESIC’s recommendations. That’s not a bad thing, but fans have to understand that tournament operators have a monetary stake in the ESIC’s decisions.
In order to become a member of the Commission, tournament organizers have to pay in for the privilege. Even some coaches have questioned whether the punishments will have any effect on the underlying problem at all.
Some of these orgs really are a joke, their coaches found guilty of using the bug, multiple times and with clear intent of gaining a competitive advantage and you simply move them to an “analyst” position? Seriously?
— Janko Paunovic (@YNk) October 1, 2020
Due to that monetary connection between organizers and its governing body, fans might start to look at the organization with suspicion, especially if its punishments are too hard too harsh or too soft. To make matters worse in the public eye, an ESIC tweet posted after the announcement of the CSGO coaching exploit investigation, the ESIC followed up the announcement with a tweet that raised eyebrows.
(Note: this is subject to any complications that may arise in our consultation with various stakeholders).
— ESIC (@ESIC_Official) September 24, 2020
Many wondered exactly what the ESIC meant by the tweet. The Commission did not respond to WIN.gg’s request for clarification.
Currently, several major tournament organizers are considered “stakeholders.” ESL and BLAST Entertainment are included in that list, as well as small but growing organizers like WePlay!, who also host CSGO tournaments. More questions arose when fans got a good look at the relatively minor penalties handed down by the Commission and its commissioner Ian Smith.
Instead of completely banning the coaches, most are required to stay a certain distance away from the team before and during matches as well as CSGO’s common map veto stage. This has resulted in several teams simply moving the sanctioned coaches to analyst positions where they can effectively act as a coach, just not inside the server during official matches….
Read More:Source link